-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Ciri actress asks fans to give Liam Hemsworth a chance as Geralt of Rivia
balls of snow
Member
We will see how good you really are Ciri in an Apes film next week. Baghead was mid.
zkorejo
Member
Nothing against Liam. The fuckin showrunner and writers are biggest bunch of losers I have ever seen.
They stumbled upon goldmine and still managed to fuck it all up. They had best Witcher, a huge audience from start, so much buzz, books easy to translate over for tv show.. just how silly one has to be to fuck it up that bad.
I would have stopped after 2nd season (that finale was atrocious), but stayed for Henry. Now that he's gone there's no hope.
They stumbled upon goldmine and still managed to fuck it all up. They had best Witcher, a huge audience from start, so much buzz, books easy to translate over for tv show.. just how silly one has to be to fuck it up that bad.
I would have stopped after 2nd season (that finale was atrocious), but stayed for Henry. Now that he's gone there's no hope.
Last edited:
Tommi84
Member
Please, don't ever show this picture anywhere. That's NOT Triss that anyone asked for
xD
Dazraell
Member
To me it's not even about a new actor. This show was always awful and I don't blame lack of Cavill in a cast, but decisions of the showrunner. Even the first season, which admittedly wasn't that bad if compared to what came after had plenty of flaws and unecessary changes which made it significantly worse than a source material they based this on. So yeah, after what I saw in the past, I don't really have any hopes that Season 4 and 5 will be any better than what we got in past seasons
Randall365
Member
The first season was decent I thought - bit convoluted. The second was a disaster.
mansoor1980
Member
LordBritish
Member
They had the perfect opportunity at the end of the last season to go from Cavil to Hemmsworth via a face changing spell... i thought it was actually gonna happen when I watched that last episode....
that would of been killer
that would of been killer
AeonGaidenRaiden
Member
I have nothing against the actor, just Season 3 was crap and no matter who you put in place of Geralt now, to visually change the main actor while you already got accustomed to another actor for 4 years is such a mind fuck. Its like im watching a totally different show. Batman Begins had a different actress for his girlfriend but she was only in the first movie, not that important to the story plus there was a 3 year gap before The Dark Knight came out and im pretty sure most people didnt even notice the swap in actress. But imagine if they replaced Christian Bale as Batman, it would throw you off.
Dazraell
Member
I mean to be fair, Spartacus TV series pulled a lead actor change relatively well, all things considered. That being said, circumstances behind a lead change were very different (actor has passed away)
MagiusNecros
Gilgamesh Fan Annoyance
I'm only willing to give Witcher 4 a chance.
Panajev2001a
GAF's Pleasant Genius
At least Cavill could push back as he cared for and knew the source material, we cannot expect this from Liam Hemsworth (he did not give us any reason to do so). I wonder what the writers will do unrestrained… :/.
I don't want to see anyone interpret whatever those Witcher hating writers made, no matter the talent of the actor.
ChuckeRearmed
Member
The problem with the Witcher is not Liam...
Randall365
Member
The Striga episode early on was a good one. Telling that the writer on that one stormed off saying that many in the writing room didn’t like the source material. They should have gone off to work on that Wheel of Time nonsense and left it to people who got the character.
The Mandolorian was a good lesson in keeping your main character on screen and letting the world revolve around them and telling a coherent story. It also allows for greater variety in episodes.
The Mandolorian was a good lesson in keeping your main character on screen and letting the world revolve around them and telling a coherent story. It also allows for greater variety in episodes.
JimmyRustler
Member
If it soothes her mind, I wouldn’t have given the new season a chance even Cavill would have stayed. The writing is terrible.
stickkidsam
Member
Sounds like a lovely lass.
Unfortunately there seems to have been a misunderstanding.
Unfortunately there seems to have been a misunderstanding.
N1tr0sOx1d3
Given another chance
Cyberpunkd
Member
As many people said - casting was not a problem, it was the show runners that decided to treat the IP as another generic fantasy world, just with more monsters and STRONG INDEPENDENT WOMEN. All the Slavic humor (the first book starts with Geralt banding a Melitele temple girl, something that Neneke mentions after but doesn’t seem to care much), all the nuances (Nilfaard is actually the most advanced and tolerant nation, giving even dwarves and elves a semblance of normal life, whereas Northern Realms are a bunch of bigots) are gone.
Witcher has a very dedicated community, no wonder the series is getting shit.
Witcher has a very dedicated community, no wonder the series is getting shit.
existensmaximum
Member
He's not the only problem but definitely one of the biggest. Among many big problems.
Bernardougf
Member
Casting was a big fucking problem... since the beginning... the only right casting of the main characters was Geralt .. the rest? Fuck no.
The show did only one thing right in casting Cavill ... anything else was garbage.specially the story and casting for almost all female characters.
This crazy people really hate beautiful woman.
FunkMiller
Member
I stopped watching after season one, so limited chance of that happening Apes Girl.
Badlucktroll
Member
Cyberpunkd
Member
Eh, to each his own. Probably the weakest casting was Ciri, but I think her lines have a lot to do with it. Yen was quite good. Triss was an abomination.
Kiya's Guard
Member
Liam Neeson would have been a better pick, irish witcher
Denorion
Member
Didn't season 3 of the mandalorian go off rails because they wanted to focus on other characters, I didn't watch it because I heard it happens
kruis
Exposing the sinister cartel of retailers who allow companies to pay for advertising space.
I couldn't make it past the second issue of the first series. The problems with The Witcher TV show go much farther than just a different actor to play Geralt. It's *everything: the diverse casting, the nonsensical world building, the anachronisms, how Geralt is sidelined in favpr of other characters, the disdain for the source material, etc etc.
The Witcher games did everything right, all the Netflix people had to do was use that template for a tv show, but they fucked up everything because they felt they had to modernize The Witcher for modern audiences and absolutely ruined everything they touched. These people deserve the utmost ridicule and shouldn't be allowed to work in television ever again.
The Witcher games did everything right, all the Netflix people had to do was use that template for a tv show, but they fucked up everything because they felt they had to modernize The Witcher for modern audiences and absolutely ruined everything they touched. These people deserve the utmost ridicule and shouldn't be allowed to work in television ever again.
Dr.Morris79
Member
Imagine getting the rights to a well established set of books and games, then having the perfect casting for your main character but you have zero clue about either the books or the games and can't write for shit and all your other casting is absolute turd. You then ask bereft fans to give it another chance as your perfect main character cast left because it was so shit and you were a bunch of clowns but you have another main character cast..
JackMcGunns
Member
I don't think the issue is Liam Hemsworth, the issue lies with the writers.
LaughingStock
Member
I gave up after season 1. Not even Cavill could save this show.
Bernardougf
Member
Using anything from Disney Star wars as model of "what to do" is a big ginormous red flag.
Deerock71
Member
Van Dammed.
kiphalfton
Member
Ciri actress probably gave him a chance. Multiple times if you know what I mean.
Last edited:
It's gotta hurt trying to promote a show you know is basically dead. The attitude on set must have been terrible as well, or maybe Cavill was super grumpy all the time and things got better?
Normally I'd think the show would spice things up to try to woo back the core audience but I think that ship has sailed and there is no course correction possible.
Normally I'd think the show would spice things up to try to woo back the core audience but I think that ship has sailed and there is no course correction possible.
Hardensoul
Member
No thanks! I already checked out after S2 and never watched that side story!
Trogdor1123
Member
Is anyone actually hanging the shows failure on him? I haven’t seen that at all.
LordBlodgett
Member
The issue wasn't really with Henry Cavill leaving, it was and has always been the writing of this horrible, awful, no good adaptation. Hell, that IS the reason he left. I have no idea why these productions get greenlit with showrunners and writers who want to completely change the source material.
Tams
Member
That would have required skill, imagination, and knowledge from the showrunners and writers though...
thismeinteil
Member
Similar threads
- Locked