Ulysses 31
Member
PC:
Whatever PS5 version comes out, it won't be as good as the PC version can be now(let alone with a 5080/5090).
Last edited:
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Indiana Jones and The Great Circle | Review Thread
Whatever PS5 version comes out, it won't be as good as the PC version can be now(let alone with a 5080/5090).
Judge Death
Neo Member
Does the NL in your name stand for No Life?
It's on gamepass which you've been told and continue to ignore.
You think if you just repeat the same shite over and over it becomes true. Come on mate don't be like this.
Killjoy-NL
Gold Member
Except, the same thing got Tango closed.
Last edited:
Judge Death
Neo Member
What's that got to do with anything?
Killjoy-NL
Gold Member
A lot. Because it shows that even good scores can't prevent studio closure.
Last edited:
James Sawyer Ford
Member
James Sawyer Ford This game has leapfrogged into my GOTY category. No bullshit, no hyperbole. I think its incredible but I haven't finished it yet, so that could change.
My top 3 as it stands:
1. Indiana Jones GC
2. Infinite Wealth
3. AstroBot
I’ll check it out for sure. Don’t think it would be in my top 5 this year, but probably safely in my top 10.
Still wish it were 3P and had actual good combat/traversal
Last edited:
WildBoy
Member
The metacritic is.No it isn't
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
45 min with this game and it literally couldnt be done in 3rd person. You're more likely to pick up a key and manually turn it or inspect an object in your hands or manually open drawers and pack a suitcase than you are to do any kind of Uncharted action platforming. You're just not getting what kind of game it is. It can only exist in 1st person.
Last edited:
WildBoy
Member
Are you moving goal posts now with the directors cut? Lol desperate.
James Sawyer Ford
Member
Eh, that’s a stretch
You can do all that in third person or zooming in for certain moments
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
The amount of things you'd have to zoom in on is too much. Instead it zooms you out when needed.
DenchDeckard
Moderated wildly
I genuinely love that it's first person, I respect that they have done their thing and it's not just another uncharyed/tomb raider clone.
Xdrive05
Member
Is frame generation broken for anyone else, with full path tracing on at least? In the starting jungle area, FG just randomly turns itself off and back on, making your FPS drop intensely such that it looks like frame time spikes (stutter). Turning FG off, the FPS is completely stable.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
I tend to agree.
Especially in the catabombs stage I'm in right now, third person would lead to lots of camera clipping and just poor navigation.
Machine Games decision to stick to first person for this was correct, they added lots of third person cut-aways for animations to show off the Indy model and that's pretty sufficient.
Fess
Member
Yeah don’t hesitate if you’re a fan. If you like the old movies you’ll 100% love this, I was grinning from ear to ear the first hour or so
was sooo good they absolutely nailed the feeling 
And so far it’s just getting better the more I play, it’s been stomping up my GOTY list over the whole weekend.
King Dazzar
Member
Mate, I've been playing it. Its good/solid, but it certainly isn't amazing by any stretch. On XSX at least anyway. In fact I'd say its a wait for sale when it comes to PS5. But hey to each their own.
Balducci30
Member
It’s definitely GOTY material. I don’t know what the argument here is - what else competes with it? FFVII, Astrobot, Helldivers 2, Black Myth? I’d say out of those it’s at least top 2/3
rofif
Can’t Git Gud
FF7, Dragons Dogma2, astro bot, black myth, metapor.
And my GOTY - Stellar Blade.
But other than that, indiana seems solid. I will reserve my judgement until playing
King Dazzar
Member
You're right in so far as its not been the greatest of years in my mind. All my favourites have either been remasters or games from previous years revisited with the Pro. Though I'm yet to fully get into DD2 or FFVII rebirth. But for me Indiana is good, but not great. I'm still early on though.
Balducci30
Member
I couldn’t get into dragons dogma. Didn’t play Stellar Blade. FF7 was good but not my thing.
I’d put indiana jones or astrobot as my GOTY. But I ultimately think both are solid 8’s. It hasn’t been a strong year for my personal taste.
Zathalus
Member
Why can’t Indiana Jones be a GotY contender? It has got the review scores for it, as well as good users scores. It might not be a massive critical success, or you might personally not enjoy it, but it absolutely meets the needed criteria for a GotY pick.
I don’t personally think it would (or should) win, but I don’t see why a nomination would be off the cards.
I don’t personally think it would (or should) win, but I don’t see why a nomination would be off the cards.
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
Personally I think I'm done participating in GOTY. What used to be a fun and enjoyable way to share games lists, opinions and suggestions has devolved into nothing more than a toxic exercise in conformity and gatekeeping.
King Dazzar
Member
And I'm out. I'm glad others are loving this. Unfortunately the more I play the more I dont like it. It looks mediocre on the XSX, good at times and then pretty awful at others. Good HDR, though again only at times. But I just cant get into the combat/stealth gameplay. The AI is dumb as fuck and all I'm doing is walking/crawling around crouched then whacking nazis over the head with crappy objects. It was ok for 5minutes. I'm finding its getting too tedious.
I enjoyed the story telling, but things like making you pack a suitcase. Who gets off on this shit? Its tedious.
I'm genuinely left scratching my head with the hype on here for this. The story is fairly good and the way its presented is very good and inline with films. Nah, I just dont get it gameplay wise.
To each their own. But I'm done. Not for me.
I enjoyed the story telling, but things like making you pack a suitcase. Who gets off on this shit? Its tedious.
I'm genuinely left scratching my head with the hype on here for this. The story is fairly good and the way its presented is very good and inline with films. Nah, I just dont get it gameplay wise.
To each their own. But I'm done. Not for me.
James Sawyer Ford
Member
This is what I’m afraid of
But I’m hoping I can put that aside and enjoy it anyway
I’m not seeing anything ambitious scope wise here from a gameplay pov
Last edited:
King Dazzar
Member
I think the story telling is good. And maybe if I was on a high end PC instead, then it may have carried me further. Its maybe worth noting, I didn't think much of Dishonoured either. But I did enjoy Wolfenstein 2. As controversial as this next statement is - in no way shape or form is this on the same level for me as the likes of Uncharted 4. It just aint. But imo they're both very different games.
DenchDeckard
Moderated wildly
Yeah this is dishonored lite and escape from butcher bay. If you dont like that kind of game I don't think this is going to be for you.
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
1) Todd Howard, 2) Me.
Probably helps that I just finished Still Wakes the Deep this morning and loved it. In that game a lot of the stuff you're doing is just closing valves, hitting switches. Just small little tactile additions to strengthen your physical interactions in the world. I love it. Turning keys, manually opening chests. Just makes it more immersive.
James Sawyer Ford
Member
Are you a VR fan?
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Because ..
Well then this wasn't the game for you, glad you realized it early on.
King Dazzar
Member
I think thats fair. As I also didnt enjoy escape from butchers bay - despite being a huge fan of the Riddick films.
DenchDeckard
Moderated wildly
Yup. I don't know what it is but the pace for this is glorious to me. I love the unlocking doors. Choosing keys etc. Feels tactile and I am genuinely Indy just strutting around investigating and unearthing everything that links this big larger piece to the puzzle.
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
I have enjoyed stuff on Quest 2. Playing Triangle Strategy in my spare time now. Need to dig in more if I have free time. I actually have the space for full room scale stuff now that I moved.
Games of Today
Member
Just got to the obligatory sweet baby lesbian scene. They really couldn’t wait to show it to me.
Sweet Baby’s contributions to this game so far:
- Deaf character
- Woman with a contemporary short haircut
- Joke about men being insecure
- Lesbian character
I actually think it’s mandatory to include these things if you make a corporate AAA game now.
Sweet Baby’s contributions to this game so far:
- Deaf character
- Woman with a contemporary short haircut
- Joke about men being insecure
- Lesbian character
I actually think it’s mandatory to include these things if you make a corporate AAA game now.
Last edited:
ultrazilla
Gold Member
Thanks for saving me money.
Update 12/11/24
Edit: I can do better. I shall be buying this.
Last edited:
James Sawyer Ford
Member
Games of Today
Member
Someone will eventually mod it. A majority of Indy’s animations play out with a full body. It’ll be like the Cyberpunk 3rd person mod.
Games of Today
Member
No problem haha. Luckily it’s not extremely obnoxious yet but it did make me audibly sigh because, of course this is all in here.
On the flip side, the first 6 hours of the game have been fucking awesome. It really does feel like an Indy movie in first person. The punching is awesome, the whip is sick as shit and I actually cannot believe how much of the world I can interact with. There are so many physics objects and the environment art is outstanding with how much debris is strewn about the levels. They even have swaztikas in the game, not only on flags but even the smaller ones on uniforms.
Everything is here, but they just couldn’t help themselves.
deriks
4-Time GIF/Meme God
If is just this I'm totally fine
Games of Today
Member
But on the flip side. I'm fucking screaming at the quality of this game, especially after turning path tracing on.
Last edited:
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Seems like my hunch of it being removed or reduced in visibility just for marketing / trailers was right.
Games of Today
Member
Absolutely. It’s honestly a friggin miracle it’s even in the game. But at least they are actually trying to stick to the version of reality Dr. Jones lives in.
Seems like my hunch of it being removed or reduced in visibility just for marketing / trailers was right.
A ton of these are in other games with no SB involvement, and short haircuts were also a thing in the 1930s.
Last edited:
Bungie
Member
Last edited:
Killjoy-NL
Gold Member
What I don't get is how your closing comment is somehow controversial. You don't even need to play the game to come to that conclusion.
Almost all regulars here have 30+ years of experience playing games. We've played hundreds of games.
People are way too worried about being 'politicallt correct' out of fear of offending some randoms on the internet.
Edit:
Talking in general, not directed at you personally.
Last edited:
Similar threads
- Locked