-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Punished Miku
Human Rights Subscription Service
D+. The format of the show wasn't that great honestly, kind of difficult to tell which things were coming to GP with the way they did the GP graphic. Was "available with GP" supposed to reference the game they just showed or the game coming up? Also really not a lot of announcements in general for GP. Trials of Mana is just not something I'm getting excited about, but I'll try it. Guess I'll try All You Need is Help today. Could be alright.
Mostly just 3rd party stuff I knew about, or stuff that wasn't that great. Threads of Time is the standout new game announcement. Atelier looks pretty good. Still worth a watch, but underwhelming compared to some of their past shows.
Mostly just 3rd party stuff I knew about, or stuff that wasn't that great. Threads of Time is the standout new game announcement. Atelier looks pretty good. Still worth a watch, but underwhelming compared to some of their past shows.
Last edited:
Coloress_Kafka
Member
F for the fantasy of Final Fantasy 16 being there.
ChuckeRearmed
Member
I will go with C. Not great, not terrible. Some neat surprises, but nothing special.
analog_future
Resident Crybaby
Jez Corden is completely wrong like 95% of the time.
What was he predicting?
I personally blame Tom for this one
Rumor - "Gonna be worth tuning into the Xbox Tokyo game show stream next week" says Tom Warren
Gonna be worth tuning into the Xbox Tokyo game show stream next week
PuppetMaster
Member
Meh
Last edited:
ChorizoPicozo
Member
Indiana Jones didn't have a release date?
FeralEcho
Member
And that's your opinion,which is fine. I have a different one.You don't have to share it nor did I ask you to.
Gamer_By_Proxy
Member
holy goo goo gaa gaa batman
HeWhoWalks
Gold Member
I mean, yeah, it’s a message board. That’s how it works.
For a tgs show I thought it was pretty good. Much better than what Sony brought. I'm slightly mixed on my rating of A for this since the only reason I did so was because I think I rated the Sony show a "B". I think this is honestly a rating of B and Sony is now a rating of C. I would have liked more new stuff. This felt more like an update.
Shadowstar39
Member
If all I had was an xbox, (I own ps5/xbx/switch/pc/quest/steam deck) I would be ok with this and rate it a solid "C" , but as a multi-device owner, its meh.
It's the "We're getting it too, only late" show.
Seriously. Mana, and Final Fantasy, where was this years ago? Obviously xbox doesn't have the crowd for that as it's the cod/fortnite/gamepass console. Shit I can't even say Halo/Gears/Forza anymore as it's not pumping them out and they aren't getting bought like they were, sad times.
Suikoden and DQ3 remake are the stars of the show here, but they are known and also coming everywhere else. I am getting them on the switch as that is where i tend to play grind heavy jrpgs or roguelikes if I can help it.
It's the "We're getting it too, only late" show.
Seriously. Mana, and Final Fantasy, where was this years ago? Obviously xbox doesn't have the crowd for that as it's the cod/fortnite/gamepass console. Shit I can't even say Halo/Gears/Forza anymore as it's not pumping them out and they aren't getting bought like they were, sad times.
Suikoden and DQ3 remake are the stars of the show here, but they are known and also coming everywhere else. I am getting them on the switch as that is where i tend to play grind heavy jrpgs or roguelikes if I can help it.
Thabass
Member
ExtendEmbraceExtinguish
Member
I have not finished watching the stream. But if that list is all gp titles then it’s a megaton. Will place a review later.
POKEYCLYDE
Member
Nothing really new. Some things I'm interested in, but doesn't move the needle for a show. Solid D.
Timberwolf25
Member
Voted C, same rating I gave the SoP. Wanted to give it a D+ so rounded up
Edit: After watching it again, I would've changed my rating to a C+/B-. I'd say I would probably play more than half of these titles if they were on GamePass for sure
Also, the Japanese host is cute, so extra points for that
Edit: After watching it again, I would've changed my rating to a C+/B-. I'd say I would probably play more than half of these titles if they were on GamePass for sure
Also, the Japanese host is cute, so extra points for that
Last edited:
Lucifers Beard
Member
It wasn't for me, but I know that what they showed would definitely have appealed to a decently sized audience.
FeralEcho
Member
HeWhoWalks
Gold Member
I know, fascinating. Apparently you learned something new today.
FeralEcho
Member
Nah, I just stated my opinion,you are the one pushing through with this senseless conversation all because you seemed to have a problem with my personal feelings about the industry lmao
Some self reflection would be terrific for you before you start being passive agressive with your posts.
Also tell me how much I owe you as I seem to be living rent free in your head today.
HeWhoWalks
Gold Member
“Senseless conversation” while you continue to quote me!
I have nothing to reflect on. You gave your piece - I gave mine. We didn’t agree. You tell me it’s a message board. I concurred (even if you didn’t like the words used, that’s what happened). You then quote me with a snarky gif, then complain about passive aggression.
We should be done here, so what is left to discuss, ma’am/sir?
Last edited:
FeralEcho
Member
We were done 3 posts ago. Good day to you!
HeWhoWalks
Gold Member
Good day.
Last edited:
Bartski
Gold Member
Sure was
playbignbox
Member
Xbox at TGS is always a C at best. I'd give this one a D because there was an expectation that they'd announce FF16 or another bigger game.
ExtendEmbraceExtinguish
Member
7 to 8 due to gp titles and showing actual good gameplay of titles coming out soon. Slitherhead/ Chrono Trigger inspired game and dragon quest 2hd looked great.
This actually looked better than state of play; and the worse part is the last sop before this recent one looked better.
The funniest part is Japanese developers giving actual reasons for why their games exist, slitherhead legend stating how the game’s mechanics forces the player to change strategy with his title.
just straight design philosophy that should be showcased in both msft main show and Sonys upcoming real showcase. More gameplay please.
This actually looked better than state of play; and the worse part is the last sop before this recent one looked better.
The funniest part is Japanese developers giving actual reasons for why their games exist, slitherhead legend stating how the game’s mechanics forces the player to change strategy with his title.
just straight design philosophy that should be showcased in both msft main show and Sonys upcoming real showcase. More gameplay please.
apocaliptic
Member
Did they had a showcase? Why?
March Climber
Member
Low C- for me. This was more for Xbox fans rather than video game fans in general like their summer show.
Similar threads
- Poll