Why do you feel this way?
As a newish tank (I played PLD in 2.0 but I maybe played 2.1 and then left? I dunno, I had my Relic weapon at Zenith level) and trying to pick it back up again, there's something better?
Not asking aggressively, genuinely curious. Want to be as good as I can be and it seems like a decent buff.
30% parry isn't good, especially not on Paladin. I'd rather people pack Reprisal, which I feel many don't. Rampart/Conv/Provoke/Reprisal/Shirk I think is the best tank set up, and swapping in something like Awareness instead of Shirk for dungeon runs is probably best.
Parry as far as I know caps out at 20% mitigation, which is less than Paladins block for. Also pretty sure the game rolls for Parry before Block, so you end up taking more damage if you parry than if you would have blocked on Paladin.
Been trying to level WHM a little since 4.0 and tanks that have felt very squishy tended to really enjoy using Anticipation. As opposed to something like Rampart/Conv/Awareness/Reprisal, it's a 30% parry rate increase, which means you may get mitigation or you may not. Awareness is kind of in the same boat of RNG, but at least you are guaranteeing you cannot be crit during its duration.
I dunno. I think Anticipation is a trap and not really useful at all. Dark Knights still love it even though their entire synergy with parry has been scrapped. Confusing, to say the least.