Support NeoGAF

[Pranay]

Can someone help me rounding up the scores :|

 

[BiggNife]

ya, an 8 is beyond pathetic and just a lame attempt at getting some extra hits.

Oh yeah, I'm sure you've played the game at this point so you know the game definitely doesn't deserve an 8.

Christ people, relax. It's one score. It's like 8.8-gate all over again.

 

[diffusionx]

How dare Eurogamer's writer express his opinion.

Maybe he just doesn't think the game is worth a 9 or a 10. I just played through Uncharted 2, 8/10 is the score I would give it.

 

[Chinner]

review drama has started already

 

[Biggest-Geek-Ever]

Add the scores which i missed out

Magzine Reviews

Playmania [Spain] - 9.9

Official Playstation Magzine [Spain] - 9.8

Power Unlimited - 94

PS Mania - 4.5/5

Level Magzine - 10/10 [second opinion - 8/10]

PlayR - 9/10


Website Reviews -
ign - 10


Gamersnet - 10/10
http://www.gamersnet.nl/reviews/uncharted_3_drake_s_deception/

Being Nerdy - 10/10
http://beingnerdy.com/gaming/uncharted-3-drakes-deception-review

XGN -94
http://www.xgn.nl/ps3/review/31234/uncharted-3-drakes-deception/

Edge - 9

jeuxvideo.fr - 9/10

Dannish ign - 9.5
http://de.ign.com/articles/review/10457/Test-zu-Uncharted-3/p4

CVG 9.5

GiantBomb : 5/5

Joystiq 4.5/5
http://www.joystiq.com/2011/10/24/un...eption-review/

1up.com: A.

gamereactor - 10/10

playstationlife - 10/10

Just beautiful.

 

[djplaeskool]

With that, Naughty Dog cannot make UC4 now because everyone is having a shitfit about how it's a sequel.

Unless it really is a kart racing game.

 

[Callibretto]

The execution exhibits a kind of workmanship and polish way beyond the ambition of most other developers, let alone their abilities or budgets. As an expression of all that a video game could be, however, Uncharted 3 is narrow, focused and ultimately shallow

this is basically the summary of eurogamer review, and I know some reviewer will say this. Uncharted is a very straight forward series, it's gamey element is very simple compared to other games like skyrim, zelda, deus ex

 

[delta25]

but an 8 means it is a good game! how is an 8 pathetic!

when every other review is giving it a near perfect score, something seems a bit fishy.

 

[Angry Fork]

Arne
Critical Acclaim; again. Deal with it.

 

[Y2Kev]

Unless it really is a kart racing game.

Unkarted: the narrative does not fit with the gameplay. how can we take nathan drake seriously in a kart? he is an everyman. he should be complaining of sore kart muscles after karting for multiple hours.

 

[ThisWreckage]

I seriously started ignoring Eurogamer a long time ago. When other publications and sites are giving the game high 9's to perfect 10's and then Eurogamer comes along and gives it an 8 I can't help but laugh. What's sad is that their 8 score will garner a ton of hits and they know it.

 

[eternaLightness]

I know Naughty Dog has big happy smiles on their faces right now.

 

[Dragon]

How dare Eurogamer's writer express his opinion.

Maybe he just doesn't think the game is worth a 9 or a 10. I just played through Uncharted 2, 8/10 is the score I would give it.

That same writer gave a Gundam game the same 8/10 score. I don't really care what you rate it, since you're not a professional reviewer, just seems a bit weird to give those two games similar scores.

 

[Nirolak]

With that, Naughty Dog cannot make UC4 now because everyone is having a shitfit about how it's a sequel.

You say this like it has ever stopped Sony before.

 

[Sneds]

review drama has started already

It's so sad.

People need to look up 'subjective' in the dictionary.

 

[Poker360]

I seriously started ignoring Eurogamer a long time ago. When other publications and sites are giving the game high 9's to perfect 10's and then Eurogamer comes along and gives it an 8 I can't help but laugh. What's sad is that their 8 score will garner a ton of hits and they know it.

It's great, they countered the biased Greg Miller review.

 

[Gravijah]

when every other review is giving it a near perfect score, something seems a bit fishy.

so a reviewer isn't allowed to have an opinion? his score has to be in line with the metacritic score? what's the point in even reviewing a game, then?

That same writer gave a Gundam game the same 8/10 score. I don't really care what you rate it, since you're not a professional reviewer, just seems a bit weird to give those two games similar scores.

i don't see what's so strange about that.

 

[BeeDog]

The game is fucking killing it. Woo!

 

[GeoramA]

Straight 10s from IGN...wow

And 9.5 from GT?

I didn't think this game would score higher than UC2, glad I was wrong

 

[Tricky I Shadow]

A mod should add ‘IGN – 10/10’ in the title.

 

[Gafapastismo]

That review had some serious hyperbole in it. You mean to tell me that the game has absolutely no fucking flaws? 10 on graphics?

Are you serious? IGN gave a 10 in graphics a lot of games with worst graphics than Uncharted 3

 

[Bad_Boy]

Unless it really is a kart racing game.

 

[Auto_aim1]

Game of the forever. Truly is. Cannot wait.

 

[Pranay]

nowgamer - 9.7

 

[Dragon]

so a reviewer isn't allowed to have an opinion? his score has to be in line with the metacritic score? what's the point in even reviewing a game, then?

So we can use it in list wars against Gears of War 3. Obvi.

Are you serious? IGN gave a 10 in graphics a lot of games with worst graphics than Uncharted 3

Yeah Jarmel seems to have concentrated on the graphics part which is strange. I think people agree that the Uncharted series have great graphics.

i like how an 8/10, let's repeat that an 8/10, is suddenly a troll review.

Gundam.

 

[Empty]

i like how an 8/10, let's repeat that actually, - an 8/10 - is suddenly a troll review score.

 

[Snipes424]

Uncharted 3 is on par with Dynasty Warriors Gundam 3 according to the same reviewer.

Hell yeah. So Hyped for UC3. Pre-order back on.

...

Idontwanttoliveonthisplanetanymore.jpg

 

[3N16MA]

UC3 kicking ass. Lots of great games in 2011 but this is my most anticipated and most likely GOTY.

 

[spats]

PSNation: A+

http://www.psnation.org/2011/10/24/review-uncharted-3-drakes-deception-ps3/

 

[Auto_aim1]

so a reviewer isn't allowed to have an opinion? his score has to be in line with the metacritic score? what's the point in even reviewing a game, then?
i don't see what's so strange about that.

Different reviewers. Bramwell reviewed UC2 and gave it a 10. This one is by Parkin, but still considering the average, it should have been a 9.

 

[diffusionx]

That same writer gave a Gundam game the same 8/10 score. I don't really care what you rate it, since you're not a professional reviewer, just seems a bit weird to give those two games similar scores.

Maybe he likes Gundam as much or more than Uncharted 3?

 

[ThisWreckage]

It's great, they countered the biased Greg Miller review.

Eurogamer's gimmick has been being notoriously hard on games in the past. Par for the course here.

 

[marathonfool]

You all need to stop focusing on the one good rating and focus on all the great-pefect scores.

This is exactly why I pre-ordered this game when it was announced. Congrats to Naughty Dog. Another terrific piece of interactive entertainment.

 

[Tricky I Shadow]

Game of the forever. Truly is. Cannot wait.

 

[BiggNife]

when every other review is giving it a near perfect score, something seems a bit fishy.

SOMEONE HAS AN OPINION WHO THAT ISN'T THE SAME AS EVERYONE ELSE'S

HE IS UNPURE

ESCORT HIM TO THE FIRING RANGE

 

[C_H_T]

Gamesradar - 9

http://www.gamesradar.com/uncharted-3-drakes-deception-review/?page=3

Videogamer.com - 9

http://www.videogamer.com/ps3/uncharted_3/review-3.html

GamesTM - 9

http://www.gamestm.co.uk/reviews/uncharted-3-drakes-deception-review/

G4TV - 4/5

http://www.g4tv.com/games/ps3/64706/uncharted-3-drakes-deception/review/

 

[DevelopmentArrested]

i like how an 8/10, let's repeat that an 8/10, is suddenly a troll review.

when you say that playstation mini's are more innovative than uncharted 3, it is.

 

[Loudninja]

Gamepro 5/5
http://www.gamepro.com/article/reviews/224128/review-uncharted-3-drakes-deception-ps3/

 

[SuicidalSteve]

This Uncharted 3 review from Eurogamer is the lowest scoring out of the whole trilogy from their website

 

[KingK]

Eh, that Eurogamer review was kinda shitty. The whole thing read like "This game is unparalleled as a linear game experience, but it's not risky and it's a linear game. I don't like linear games. 8/10." I hate when linear game design is used as a criticism.

edit: It's also odd, considering they gave UC2 a 10/10. Different reviewers I guess?

 

[Gravijah]

when you say that playstation mini's are more innovative than uncharted 3, it is.

playstation minis can be quite innovative, i don't see the issue with that statement.

 

[DaBuddaDa]

Between This, Portal 2, Deus Ex: Human Revolution, Gears of War 3, Batman Arkham City, Battlefield 3, Skyward Sword, Dark Souls, Bastion and Skyrim, this year's GOTY is going to be epic.

 

[Y2Kev]

You say this like it has ever stopped Sony before.

It's insomniac's MO!

 

[Dragon]

SOMEONE HAS AN OPINION WHO THAT ISN'T THE SAME AS EVERYONE ELSE'S

HE IS UNPURE

ESCORT HIM TO THE FIRING RANGE

Hey Kirby. Calm down kid.

 

[Dr. Malik]

It's great, they countered the biased Greg Miller review.

Gamepro 5/5
http://www.gamepro.com/article/reviews/224128/review-uncharted-3-drakes-deception-ps3/

 

[brandonh83]

have outdone themselves

 

[PowderedToast]

I seriously started ignoring Eurogamer a long time ago. When other publications and sites are giving the game high 9's to perfect 10's and then Eurogamer comes along and gives it an 8 I can't help but laugh. What's sad is that their 8 score will garner a ton of hits and they know it.

oh god why did i click on this thread i knew i knew i knew

 

[nelsonroyale]

this is basically the summary of eurogamer review, and I know some reviewer will say this. Uncharted is a very straight forward series, it's gamey element is very simple compared to other games like skyrim, zelda, deus ex

I dont feel either zelda or deus ex are especially complex...infact deus ex especially seemed pretty damn stream lined...the game allowed an impressive amount of freedom in some aspects, but they seemed to have compromized on the level design...most areas felt like carbon copies with a few layout changes

 

[marc^o^]

GOTY, brought to you by Naughty Dog.

 

[ProfessorMoran]

Arne
Critical Acclaim; again. COME AT ME BRO.

Fixed.